American Muslims say discrimination is on the rise
Tuesday, September 19,
2006
By JOHN CHADWICK
STAFF WRITER
|
|
A record number of American Muslims said they
were victims of discrimination in 2005, a national
Islamic group said Monday.
The Council on American-Islamic Relations said it
received nearly 2,000 civil rights complaints,
ranging from reports of physical violence to mosque
desecration to verbal abuse.
The numbers, released in a 46-page report by the
council, are the highest in the agency's 12-year
history and reflect a 30 percent jump from 2004.
The report comes five years after 9/11 at a time
when public opinion polls show a growing public
unease with Muslims and Islam.
"It is apparent that post-9/11 backlash against
Muslims, Arabs and South Asians continues to be a
societal problem," the report said. "With the recent
renewal ... of the infamous USA Patriot Act, it is
imperative for our society to ensure that all
Americans are treated equally under the law."
In New Jersey, home to an estimated 300,000
Muslims, the number of complaints -- 70 --
represented an increase of one from 2004, but was
enough to make the state the 10th highest in the
nation.
And, some of the complaints attracted national
attention -- including an incident in which several
Muslim men were detained at a Giants football game
in the Meadowlands after they were seen praying in a
corridor.
The report said the most common complaint, about
17 percent, was what it called due process
violations and included improper arrest, detentions
and interrogations.
Some of the more serious cases in the report
include the pipe bombing of a Cincinnati mosque, and
the firing of 50 shots at two cars at a Philadelphia
mosque.
Arsalan Iftikhar, the author of the report,
described a second New Jersey case in which a man
who worked in Wayne was harassed by his co-workers
after they found religious books on his desk. The
books were thrown in the trash, and a co-worker
declared, "These [expletive] books don't belong
here!"
Meanwhile, a Wyckoff man who runs the council's
New Jersey chapter said many of the complaints he
handled were lodged by workers who were told to
shave their beards or remove their head scarves.
"We're seeing a deliberate identification of the
Muslim in the workplace," Mir Ali said. "People are
more quick to identify Muslims and raise these
issues."
A Middlesex County man, for example, said his
wife was working as a supermarket cashier when she
was told by the manager to leave her head scarf at
home.
"They said you can't have any religion at the
store," said the man, who requested anonymity
because his wife still works at the store. "When we
told them it was a religious obligation, they asked
us to bring a letter from a religious authority."
The matter wasn't settled, however, until the
council sent letters to the store's corporate
offices that explained how personal displays of
religion are protected by the Constitution.
"Once they knew the law, they respected it," the
man said.
Demeaning comments
Other common complaints, Ali said, include rude
behavior by government workers, such as federal
immigration officials. More common, he said, are
demeaning comments. He said one headscarf-wearing
woman said she was approached by another woman, who
said: "You don't have to wear that now, honey,
you're in America."
Still, some community activists said the New
Jersey numbers show the state remains a relatively
hospitable state for Muslims and Arab Americans.
"We'll always have issues in the airports," said
Hani Khoury, a lawyer in Hackensack, and president
of the state chapter of the American Arab
Anti-Discrimination Committee. "But we generally
feel the state is aware of our issues and is anxious
to work with us to solve them."
Clifton lawyer Sohail Mohammed said he has
conducted workshops on Muslim etiquette for nearly
7,000 law enforcement officers.
"I'm a firm believer that ignorance breeds fear,
and fear breeds the type of profiling that the
community fears," Mohammed said.
The report, meanwhile, dwells on the steps
Muslims have taken at the national level to clarify
the Islamic position on terrorism. But the report's
author said those steps appear to register little
with a skeptical public.
The steps include the issuing of a fatwa, or
religious ruling, saying that Islam forbids violence
against civilians. The council also took to
television for 30-second public-service
advertisements.
"We feel like we've stood on every street corner
yelling at the top of our lungs," said Iftikhar, the
council's legal director. "But there are people who
just don't want to hear it."
A Rutherford activist said he blames the
president, among others.
"How do you expect the numbers [of civil rights
complaints] to go down when our president is
speaking on national television about Islamic
fascism?" said Hesham Mahmoud, who works with the
American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee.
E-mail: chadwick@northjersey.com
|