Corzine steps up to plate on immigration
Wednesday, August 8, 2007
THE RECORD EDITORIAL
|
|
GOVERNOR Corzine is not trying to solve the
immigration issue with his new blue ribbon panel. He
can't, since how immigrants get here -- or don't get
here -- is a federal responsibility.
He is trying, however, to find ways to help those
hundreds of thousands of immigrants who are already
here -- both legal and illegal. Corzine wants
policies that will integrate them, not marginalize
them. The panel has been charged to look at
everything: education, citizenship rights, housing,
health care, language proficiency, employment and
job training.
That's an incendiary idea to those who would
rather see a crackdown on illegal immigrants and
those who hire them. They want to make it harder for
illegal immigrants to stay here, not easier. But the
mass deportation of an estimated 12 million illegal
immigrants is neither practical nor humane.
We believe the governor has the more realistic
approach: Given the stalemate in Congress, the
numbers of illegal immigrants and the economic
demand for their work, it is better to help them
become "fully productive and self-sufficient members
of society," in the governor's words. He sees that
goal as "critical to the future economic and social
well-being of the state."
However, there's no denying that problems exist:
unsafe housing, overloaded schools and medical
services in some communities, employer abuses and
crime. And many immigrants facing these challenges
are here legally.
The panel intends to hold public hearings, when
members will no doubt get an earful. But beyond the
vitriol, all reasonable viewpoints must be heard,
especially from towns dealing with large numbers of
illegal immigrants. Immigration is an extremely
complicated issue that requires the panel, as well
as local leaders, to be open-minded, pragmatic and
compassionate.
It's too bad that the panel has been given 15
months to come up with solutions. It's easy to see
this panel as an excuse for inaction, a way to stall
for time and hope the problem and the divisions will
go away.
Certainly, the quality of the four North Jersey
members belies that assumption. They are Monsignor
William Reilly of Garfield, who helps immigrants
seeking permanent residence; Samer Khalaf of
Paramus, who is with the American-Arab
Anti-Discrimination Committee; Ralph Rivera Jr. of
Ridgefield Park, a Bergen County undersheriff with
experience in community policing; and Michael
Wildes, the mayor of Englewood and an immigration
attorney.
The head of the 27-member panel is Public
Advocate Ronald Chen, another sign that its mission
will be taken seriously and its work done
thoroughly.
We hope that its work will also be done speedily.
Corzine has taken on the most divisive issue facing
the nation and the state. A report full of
recommendations that sound good but go nowhere would
be a failure. |