Muslim leaders criticize focus on suspects' religion
Wednesday, May 9, 2007
By ELIZABETH LLORENTE
STAFF WRITER
|
|
Federal prosecutors' depiction of the suspects in
the Fort Dix plot as "radical Islamists" drew sharp
criticism from North Jersey's Muslims, who feared
that the emphasis on Islam would trigger a backlash.
Arab and Muslim leaders from various national
organizations expressed their concerns in a
conference call to FBI officials about the focus on
Islam that officials used when announcing the
charges.
They said in a statement that FBI officials
"assured that the charges ... are for individuals
and not for a religion or an ethnic or racial
group." Later in the day, prosecutors urged the
public not to take the alleged actions of a few as a
reflection of the Muslim community.
"This should not be taken as a generalized
indictment against the Muslim community in New
Jersey," U.S. Attorney Christopher Christie said. He
praised the Muslim community in New Jersey as being
cooperative with law enforcement, and called the
defendants "a few bad apples."
But concerns persisted about the impact of the
widely publicized link to Islam.
Muslim leaders said the spotlight on the
suspects' religion reinforces the stereotype that
terrorism is condoned by Islam -- an inaccurate and
harmful misperception, they say, that they have been
struggling to combat.
"I have no mercy for people who commit a crime,
or who plan to commit a crime, as these six men are
charged with," said Sohail Mohammed, a Clifton
attorney and civil rights activist. "But to make
their religion synonymous with their crime is
irresponsible, especially when it comes from a
high-level United States official."
The phrase identifying the suspects as "radical
Islamists" was part of the title of the written
announcement released by Christie's office about the
arrest of six men charged with plotting to attack
the Fort Dix Army post. The announcement then
referred to the suspects as "radical Islamists" in
the first sentence, and said they had distributed
videos that showed "known foreign Islamic radicals
urging jihad against the United States."
Salaheddin Mustafa of Paterson said the tendency
to link religion and a heinous act seems to affect
Muslims disproportionately.
"When that student in Virginia killed all those
people, nobody made a big deal of his religion,"
said Mustafa. "And when there have been shootings in
malls and offices, we don't immediately get told
what the religion is. These are six crazy people,
that's all they are."
Hesham Mahmoud of Rutherford, spokesman for the
American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, said
Christie's efforts in the press conference to
separate the suspects from Islam had prompted him to
"give him the benefit of the doubt." He said that in
the past, Christie had made admirable efforts to
reach out to the Arab and Muslim communities, as
well as other minority groups.
At a Turkish restaurant in Paterson, Farid Otman
shrugged and sighed over the prominent attention
given to the religion of the suspects.
"By now, I am used to it," said Otman, a native
of Egypt. "But the backlash is not as bad as it was
after Sept. 11. There's been a lot of improvement in
communication since then, and a lot of lines of
communication opened between Muslims and other faith
groups."
Mitchel Maddux and Samantha Henry contributed to
this article. E-mail: llorente@northjersey.com |